Machine Scoring Fails the Test

Posted: 2013/05/19 by Punkonomics (@dearbalak) in Uncategorized

Thus would have been nice for senior seminar papers… or not.

martinkich's avatarACADEME BLOG

Approved by the NCTE Executive Committee, April 2013

[A] computer could not measure accuracy, reasoning, adequacy of evidence, good sense, ethical stance, convincing argument, meaningful organization, clarity, and veracity in your essay. If this is true I don’t believe a computer would be able to measure my full capabilities and grade me fairly. — Akash, student

[H]ow can the feedback a computer gives match the carefully considered comments a teacher leaves in the margins or at the end of your paper? — Pinar, student

(Responses to New York Times The Learning Network blog post, “How Would You Feel about a Computer Grading Your Essays?”, 5 April 2013)

Writing is a highly complex ability developed over years of practice, across a wide range of tasks and contexts, and with copious, meaningful feedback. Students must have this kind of sustained experience to meet the demands of higher education, the needs of a…

View original post 1,857 more words

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.